I printed the rest of the dive into accessibility stuff, and the more I read the more I see parallels between the standards argument and the accessibility issues. We talked about standards sapping creativity from a web site. the question what is more important, giving the web author freedom to reign supreme over all of the work he does, or conform to certain standards set down by organizations and committees? What is more important creativity or business?
In my humble opinion both are equally important. There is really no way to separate the two, there is always going to be a creative force behind the production of a visual medium, and since the web is an interactive visual medium, there will be a creative process behind the development of web sites. So there is always creativity in the building of such things. However, I have an e-business site, and I want my web site built in a certain way, then creative liberties taken with my site, without my approval will be discouraged. The idea of creative liberty has an even greater relevance with a company or institution that is creating a brand identity. The developer must create within the context and framework of the reigning standards organization and if he or she want to express their virtual liberties without the boundaries of the standards board, then let them go and built on their own plot of land, they are getting paid to do a job, if the job specifies to use blue paint on the border, and make sure there is a search engine on each page, then you are obligated to do follow the rules, if not, then let somebody else do the job.
If you are a punk and subscribe to the whatever, wherever, whenever school, get your own site, and flail away at it, but if you are contracted to do a job then do it.
Barista: “Isn’t it true that standards enforce creativity as well”
JM: “Yea your right, I guess?, the standard forces you to re-think the approach,.
Barista: “Standards develop resourcefulness.”
JM: “I haven’t thought of the inverse like that yet, I was only thinking that the standards are a constricting force, not an enrichment force”.
Barista: “Do you want another bianca maraschino grade latino press?”
JM: “sure, this is the last one though, Oh well look at it this way, if your going to build a house, the building standards are only there to make the place inhabitable, if they’re weren’t any standards we would all be living like that lady in the Mother Jones article, her walls leaking, her sky light installed upside down, and the bathtub that crashed into he living room, when full.
But the idea is that as long as there are codes and standards then you can build as big and tall and wide you like, without the worry that the walls are going to come crumbling down around you.”
JM: “(slurp), Jesus man you make the best white chocolate latino I have ever tasted.!?!”
Barista:“Cheaper than a gallon of gas too”
Oh about the parallels to accessibility, next time,